7 Best Training Collar for Stubborn Dogs – Pets Guide

best training collar for stubborn dogs

Training a dog is not a straightforward task since it demands a lot of effort and time from a professional dog trainer. Therefore, different gadgets are invented over time to make this process easy and enjoyable for you. 

Besides, dogs have different breeds hence, their skin, weight, size, dog’s neck, and height also vary. Also, some dog breeds are stubborn and you can’t make them obedient by using traditional training approaches. So, when it comes to the best training collar for stubborn dogs, the decision becomes hard as they need slightly different protocols.

For them, you need to pick up a high-quality e-collar that will assist you in correcting their behavior without any hindrance. Dog collars have several different settings like the changeable strength of shock and vibration so, you always have the luxury of choosing the required setting for your dog breed.

To add more perspective to it, the best dog collars are long-lasting, equipped with an efficient battery, and have a long range. Here I have provided the list of the 10 best dog collars to help you in this regard so, let’s move forward!

Which is the best training collar for stubborn dogs?

Sportdog 425x Remote Training Dog Collar is definitely the best training collar for stubborn dogs. It is the most dependable & effective dog collar for stubborn dogs and has a great build quality and is highly durable so, a perfect choice for getting the job done.

Stubborn Dog Training Collar Reviews | By Vet Experts

SportDog 425 Stubborn Dog E Collar (Best Training Collar For Stubborn Dogs)

Specifications & Features

  • These dog training collars are designed for high-drive, more stubborn dogs by offering a higher static stimulation range than the sd-425x
  • 500-Yard range e-collar that can support training 3 dogs with the same remote with the purchase of additional collars (SDR-AS)
  • Choose to train with vibration (Buzz), Tone (beep), or 21 levels of static stimulation in either momentary (nick) or continuous.
  • Waterproof and submersible to 25 feet using dryer technology
  • Lithium Ion, rechargeable batteries feature a 2-hour quick charge, and a low battery indicator lets you know when to charge.
  • Fits dogs 8 pounds or larger with neck sizes 5 – 22

Adding to this, it features seven settings and gives you the luxury of picking up the desired stimulation level. As well as the range of this E collar is concerned, it works to 500 yards long-range, therefore, a great pick for in-field training.

For easily switching between its different intensity levels, it comes with a remote so you won’t have any trouble utilizing it. Besides, it has two options for fixing the faulty behavior of your dog including a buzzing sound and vibration.

Also, this electrical dog collar is chargeable and features a lithium-ion battery. This can be fully charged merely in two hours that can be used for more than 70 hours after charging once.  The SportDog 425 shock collar is waterproof and can submerge in water for more than 25 feet.

On the bright side, this collar contains easy-to-adjust settings along with four various modes. These modes include shock, vibration, light as well as beep hence, you can always choose accordingly. Also, it contains an LCD screen which has a range of 1200ft so what else you can ask for?

  • Waterproof
  • Rechargeable battery
  • Customizable button options
  • Seven static stimulation levels
  • An additional collar can be added
  • Expensive
  • Only 500 yards limited range

Our Review

It is an ideal option for all those pet parents who want to have a comfortable, easily adjustable, and strong dog collar to train their stubborn dogs.

PetSafe Stubborn Dog Collar with 2 Free Batteries

Specifications & Features

  • Compatible with PetSafe in-ground fences except for UltraSmart In-Ground Fence PIG00-13619 and YardMax Fence PIG00-11115
  • 4 adjustable levels of static correction, plus tone with vibration only option with the push of a button
  • Also compatible with the Indoor Pet Barrier Transmitter (PIRF-100) to protect your pet indoors
  • Comes with short and Long probes and Test Tool
PetSafe Collar

Our next product is the PetSafe brand which is made using plastic as well as nylon and comes with a red collar strap. Adding to this, this awesome shock collar not only has a good design but also works great in all conditions. So, let’s check its other specific details to have a better idea about it. 

As well as its training modes are concerned, it has 4 adjustable levels of static correction, therefore, an ideal option for stubborn dogs. Besides, if you only want to use vibrations then it has a separate push-button for this purpose. 

Other than that, this shock collar is compatible with the Indoor pet barrier hence, worth purchasing. At the same time, its PIRF-100 helps to protect your pets indoors so, you can rely on it for training them.

Moreover, it features short and long probes to effectively train your dog in various conditions. Besides, it contains a test tool and you will also get two free batteries in the pack. Another great feature of the PetSafe shock collar is that it has a reasonable price so a great pick for all those pet parents who have low budgets.

Although, it has a budget-friendly price still it is great in terms of durability and can conveniently bear harsh weather conditions.

  • Budget-friendly price
  • Features a tone with vibration
  • Contains two free batteries
  • 4 adjustable of static correction
  • Its design could be better

Our Review

The customers greatly like this underground fence shock collar because of its greater accuracy and reasonable price hence, a good pick for training dogs.

PetSafe Stay & Play Wireless Fence for Stubborn Dogs

Specifications & Features

  • NO WIRE TO BURY: A wireless boundary allows you to create a safe barrier around your yard to protect your pets without spending time burying wires
  • FOR STUBBORN DOGS: The system features a tone-only mode plus 5 levels of adjustable static correction to appropriately match the temperament of even the most persistent pets
  • STATIC-FREE REENTRY: Allows your pet to return home without being corrected if your pet passes the boundary
  • SIMPLE SET-UP: Set up your new wireless fence in 1-2 hours. Receiver collar charges in 2-3 hours and each charge last for 3 weeks
  • PORTABLE: Take this portable fence with you when you and your dog go camping or travel in your RV (outlet required)

Next on the list is a wireless fence system for stubborn dogs which has a simple set-up and long range. Besides, this dog shock collar is durable so, you can use it for a long time after purchasing once. Scroll down to read the main features, merits as well as demerits of this dog shock collar.

Speaking about its range, it covers more than ¾ acre long circular area and comes with a portable indoor transmitter. The issue with most wired shock collars is that you have to purchase separate wires for them and it’s also less effective. 

However, this is not the case with this collar as it creates a wireless boundary hence, provides a safe barrier to your pet. Needless to say, this will not only save you extra expenditure on purchasing wires but will also be more useful in protecting your canine. 

Furthermore, it is specially crafted for stubborn dogs and contains a tone-only mode with 5 levels of adjustable static correction. So, you can conveniently choose the desired static level according to your dog’s temperament and physical condition. Also, this fence is portable so whenever you and your dog are going out camping, you can easily carry it. 

Note that pet experts recommend that high-level shocks should be only your last choice otherwise you should avoid these. It also contains a waterproof and rechargeable receiver collar that can be conveniently accommodated around the 6-28 inches neck. Also, it has an easy setup so you can put it together merely in one or two hours without any trouble.

  • Easy setup
  • Adjustable circular range
  • Convenient to carry
  • Best for stubborn dogs
  • Expensive

Our Review

This is simple, easy to set, and an effective dog collar that is specially designed for stubborn dogs to help you in correcting their behavior.

Educator ET-402 Two Dog E-Collar

Specifications & Features

  • A two-dog system with up to a 3/4 mile range
  • Small receiver (2×1.5×1, 2.4 oz) for dogs 5 pounds and larger
  • The ergonomic stopwatch design transmitter allows you to watch your dog at all times and includes two sets of contact points (5/8 and 3/4)
  • Delivers a tapping sensation similar to vibration, but more intense, making it an effective addition to the stimulation
  • User-selectable stimulation levels from 1 to 100 with additional boost stimulus selectable from 1 to 60, Lithium-polymer rechargeable batteries with dual charger; 2-hour full charge

The Educator ET-402 is a simple dog training collar that provides you great feasibility for teaching your dog various commands. Also, these collars don’t have any flaws and feature a half-mile range hence, a perfect option to take into consideration. Let’s have a look at all of the other features of this efficient dog collar!

First of all, I will like to unveil the most distinguishing feature that makes it unique from all other dog collars. And that is its tapping sensation in place of a beep or vibration which makes it more useful. Other than that, it comes with more than 100 various stimulation levels so, you can always choose the one according to your dog’s nature.

Needless to say, the stimulation level will further depend upon the two aspects including the size and behavior of your furry friend. Its other prominent features include a lithium polymer rechargeable battery and a biomethane collar strap. This strap is comfortable and keeps your dog’s neck at ease without leaving any harsh marks.

Besides, it has a range of half-mile therefore, you can utilize it for outdoor training as well. Additionally, you can boost up the various stimulation levels of this dog training collar according to the changing temperament of your four-legged companion. 

It is an excellent training collar with which you can not only teach your dog basic commands but can also make him an expert in hunting.

  • Comes with an LCD battery
  • Equipped with an ergonomic stopwatch
  • Features 1 to 100 stimulation levels
  • Very effective for training stubborn dogs
  • Doesn’t contain a detailed guide

Our Review

These dog training collars work by using proprietary technology for giving blunt sensation to your four-legged companion. These are better than vibrations hence, it is useful for training stubborn dogs.

Dogtra 2702T&B Two Dog Remote Training Collar

Specifications & Features

  • Bundle of 2 Items: Dogtra 2702T&B Two Dogs Remote Training Collar and PetsTEK clicker. Perfect for dogs from 35 pounds and up. Unique single-body, built-in downward-facing beeper horn to eliminate the risk of catching on obstacles when in the field. This dog behavior training collar is designed to fit dogs with neck sizes between 6 – 26 inches.
  • Product Features: Up to 1-mile range, fully waterproof ergonomic collar and receiver, 127 levels of stimulation ranging from low to high, Momentary Nick, Constant Stimulation, and Non-Stimulating High-Performance Pager Vibration modes. Dogtra’s industry-leading technology filtering system ensures minimal interference with other electronic devices. This device is a great choice for long-range upland hunting.
  • More Features: Dogtra’s 2702T&B two-dog training gives you the ability to adjust the sensitivity of the collar with ease. Select the Momentary Nick mode to deliver a single pulse of electrical stimulation. It also gives you the ability to track your dog with three beeper modes: Point-Only, Run/Point, and Locate. The beeper’s volume can also be adjusted from high to low sound levels. Equipped with the new Accelerometer sensor to give you the ability to accurately track, detect and monitor your dog.
  • Customer Service Based in the USA: The quality of the collar is unmatched in comparison to the cheaper alternatives. Dogtra Collars are helping owners to train and modify dog behavior. The advanced performance of the collar is perfectly matched with the reliable USA-based customer service that can be reached by either phone or email.
  • Positive Reinforcement: By using the PetsTEK training clicker along with your dog’s favorite treats, you can train your pet to follow your commands to become a well-behaved pooch. Please note that this collar should not be used with aggressive dogs

When it comes to attractive and sleek design, the Dogra 2702T&B will surely stand out. Besides, it is loaded with high-quality features and is undoubtedly a great option to correct the behavior of stubborn dogs. Scroll down for having a look at the basic features of this outstanding shock collar.

Adding to this, it is an ergonomically designed collar that has a range of more than one mile. The most unique feature of this shock collar is that it features 127 levels of stimulation. These levels include non-stimulating high-performance vibration modes, constant stimulation, and momentary nick.

Other than that, this two-dog remote training collar gives you the luxury of easily adjusting the sensitivity of the collar. Likewise, if you want to give a single pulse of electrical stimulation then pick up the momentary nick mode. Besides, you can also use its beeper level and can adjust the volume of the beeper mode from low to high sound levels. 

On the bright side, this shock collar is powered by the Accelerometer sensor. This unique feature gives you the luxury of monitoring, detecting, and tracking your dog without any hindrance. With this efficient device, you won’t need any pulling on the leash or barrel out of the door.  

Besides, you can encourage the positive behavior of your four-legged companion by using its petTek training clicker along with your dog’s favorite food. Therefore, it is a reliable and perfect tool to train your stubborn dog, and believe me, it will be a great addition to the accessories of your four-legged companion. 

  • Efficient battery
  • 127 levels of stimulation
  • Encourages positive behavior of the dog
  • Reliable for stubborn dogs
  • Small collar size

Our Review

This Dogtra remote training collar is wonderful in every aspect and will surely help you in making your dog obedient and disciplined.

PetSpy P620B Dog Training Collar

Specifications & Features

  • PREMIUM DOG TRAINING COLLAR- convert your dog’s behavior within days or get your Money Back; prime collar for Expert Trainers & first time Dog Owners
  • 3 TRAINING MODES – Electric Shock, Vibration, and Beep trainer with 16 adjustable levels for dogs with different sensitivity and weight
  • LIFETIME REPLACEMENT WARRANTY and 24/7 Customer Support Guarantee – buy it Risk-Free; good for all dog breeds from 10-140 lbs – Rechargeable and Waterproof dog training collar
  • BLIND OPERATION DESIGN for easy and effective dog training with Touch Distinguishing Buttons; Remote collar range is up to 650 yards
  • FREE DOG TRAINING GUIDE – get a free e-book with your order; watch very helpful training and operational videos about electronic shock collars

PetSpy is a reliable and well-known brand as it gains the trust of its customers by providing them with high-quality products. The same is the case with the PetSpy P620B dog training collar which makes it stand out among the other options available in the market. I am sure you will want to gain more knowledge about its other features so, keep on reading!

Adding to this, the most prominent feature of this dog collar is its blind operation hence, you can operate it even without looking at it. This makes it a great option for all those new dog parents who don’t know much about shock collars and their work.

Other than that, it has high static correction that’s why professional trainer uses this tool to make their dogs reliable. Besides, it has three various functions which you can either use separately or in coordination with each other to improve its performance. 

Moreover, it is equipped with 16 different levels of adjustments along with three main modes (beep, vibration, and shock). Also, it has a lifetime warranty so, you can have a hassle-free purchase without any issues.

Another great feature of this electronic collar is that it has a long range of 650 yards so what else you can demand? Besides, it is waterproof and highly suitable for a neck of 5-22 inches in thickness. It has a rechargeable battery that not only has fast charging ability but also lasts longer.

  • Effective range along with 350 yards
  • Blind operation design with 3 functional modes
  • Comes with the touch distinguishing buttons
  • Quick recharge and long-lasting battery
  • An ideal option for aggressive and stubborn dogs
  • Its stimulation is not continuous

Our Review

Thus, it is the best option for all stubborn dogs because of its 16 different stimulation levels and high accuracy. Also, it is easy to use and has distinguishable buttons for convenient operation so, a great pick for beginners as well.

Pet Union PTOZI Premium Dog Collar

Specifications & Features

  • THE ULTIMATE DOG TRAINING COLLAR – Immensely Popular, Fully Waterproof E-Collar used by Expert Trainers and First Time Pet Owners. Can be used to help correct Barking, Walking, Leash Training, Sitting, Aggression, and other Behavioral Obedience
  • HUGE LCD REMOTE WITH ADJUSTABLE SHOCK AND 4 MODES – 1-100 Level of Customization for both the Static Stimulation and Vibration.
  • LONG-LASTING BATTERY LIFE – Rapid Charging Lithium Ion Battery Provides a long-lasting Battery Life.
  • FREE EXPERT DOG TRAINING – Need dog training help? Our Expert dog trainer offers free one-on-one email advice to all customers

Although there is a large number of dog shock collars available in the market there are only a few options that are suitable for stubborn dogs. The Pet Union PTOZI is a highly efficient product that works great even for aggressive dogs. So, let’s quickly jump into the details of this strongest shock collar on the market!

Starting with its working, this collar is fully customizable which means that you can adjust it according to the changing temperament of your dog just like in the petrainer dog training collar. Also, it features four different modes including beep, light, vibration as well as shock.

Adding to this, for light training beep and vibration modes will be useful. However, if your dog shows great resistance in following your commands then go for shock mode with suitable intensity. At the same time, don’t forget to pay attention to the weight and health condition of your dog while picking up the shock intensity level.

Other than that, this premium dog collar is also equipped with a remote hence, an excellent purchase. Besides, it contains an LCD for the visual representation of different settings, so you can easily adjust these. 

Additionally, it has a long range of 1200 ft which means that it gives you the luxury of keeping an eye on your dog even when he is away from home. This shock collar utilizes a battery as a power source and it has the capability of charging within minutes. Also, it is waterproof so, your dog can swim and play in water even after wearing this collar. 

  • Easy to use
  • Comfortable to adjust
  • Comes with four vibration levels
  • Can be resized for smaller dogs
  • Features a handy remote
  • Its guide needs improvement

Our Review

The most unique feature of this collar is that it can be easily resized according to your dog’s requirements. Besides, it is packed with multiple features for advanced functionality, therefore, recommended.

Lu & Ba Shock Collar with Remote 

Specifications & Features

  • 3 TRAINING MODEc The dog shock collar has a mini size but covers 3 regular training modes. Beep Mode, Vibration, and 1~16 sensitivity level adjustable shock mode.
  • DUAL-CHANNEL AND 1000FT: The Lu&Ba remote features a dual-channel to support training 2 dogs simultaneously and help dogs learn commands efficiently and quickly.
  • WATERPROOF AND LONG BATTERY LIFE: Rated IPX7 waterproof receiver, this receiver collar can work when your dog goes for a swim, chases toys around a pool, or plays in the rain.
  • SLEEKER AND LIGHTWEIGHT: This Lu&Ba e-collar Receiver is mini. Meas.2.36(W)*1.18(W)*0.78(H)inch. Weigh only 0.12Lbs. Thin and lightweight. The Lu&Ba adjustable nylon collar fits 6-27 inches.
  • WE ARE Lu&Ba: Designed In GERMANY, With K-9 Experts. The training collar was developed and tested on dogs of different breeds and temperaments in conjunction with professional K-9 trainers.

The Lu & Ba shock collar is loaded with high-quality features that come with a handy remote so that you can easily control it. Besides, it has an eye-catching design so, a great option for all those beauty-conscious pet parents who want to enhance the looks of their dogs. Now let’s have a deeper look at the other features of this awesome shock collar.

What makes this dog collar outstanding is that it has three changeable training modes including beep, shock as well as vibration. So, whenever you want to teach your dog a new command or want to correct any of his previous bad habits then you can effortlessly use this collar.

The key feature of Lu & Ba is that it avoids any accidental shock hence, you don’t need to worry about any misoperation. This is a wonderful feature as stubborn dogs are already hard to control and if they will get hurt mistakenly then it can make their behavior worse. So, be careful in this regard and only use shock mode when the first two modes are not working in that place. 

Unless the other dog collars, this one can be used simultaneously for 2 dogs without any trouble.  Besides, this dual-channeled dog collar helps in teaching various commands to your dog quickly and effectively. 

Also, it is wireless and has a range of 1000ft so, you can easily keep your dog in check under this range. Moreover, it contains an IPX7 waterproof receiver so, your dog can easily swim around the pool and play in the rain.

  • Waterproof
  • Long battery life
  • 3 Training modes
  • Dual-Channel and 1000ft range
  • Sleek design and light in weight
  • Its vibration strength is tricky to adjust

Our Review

This is an amazing shock collar with which you can effortlessly teach your dog different commands so, highly recommended.

Garmin Delta XC Bundle-Dog Training Device

Specifications & Features

  • LONG/SHORT CONTACTS: Includes long and short changeable/replaceable contact points; Collar compatibility: 1.9 centimeters (0.75 inches)
  • STIMULATION LEVELS: Improved stimulation levels; features 18 levels of momentary and continuous stimulation, plus tone and vibration
  • RANGE: Gives 1/2 mile range capability to correct your dog’s behavior while out in the field
  • TRAINING CONFIGS : 3 correction/training configurations for different behavioral issues; Train 1, 2, or 3 dogs, settable on the handheld (with purchase of additional dog devices)
  • DURABILITY: Rugged, compact 3-button handheld controller and dog device with a water rating of IPX71.Water rating: yes (IPX7)

Another great option is Garmin Delta XC which has the capability of making disciplined even harsh dogs. Besides, this effective collar is packed with incredible features that are worthy of having a look. So, let’s move toward the main characteristics of this best dog shock collar without any further delay.

Starting with its unique point, this collar comes with a 3-button-handled control unit as well as an LCD screen. Therefore, you can have better control over multiple different settings of this remarkable dog collar.

Other than that, this collar can be utilized for three dogs at a time with the help of one receiver. It has 18 different stimulation levels hence; it gives you the luxury of optimizing the training process. Not to mention that this will further help you in fixing your dog’s behavior by encouraging good responses and resisting the bad ones. 

Besides, this collar is powered with the IPX71 therefore, you can even utilize it in the rain as It is resistant to water. At the same time, it has consecutive and momentary stimulation levels other than vibration and tones. 

Adding to this, stubborn dogs don’t get the command easily so, for them consecutive vibration will do the job. However, if your dog is not as rude and starts to follow the command with slight vibration or tone then don’t use continuous vibration for him. Besides, it comes with changeable contact points which you can remove whenever needed.

  • Initiative design
  • High battery power
  • Long-lasting and durable
  • Contains replaceable contact points
  • Has three configuration settings
  • The additional guide needed for optimal operation

Our Review

Overall, the German Delta XC is a perfect pick as it contains everything that you need in a good-quality shock collar. With its powerful battery, multiple vibration settings, and suitable range, you won’t need to use any other collar.



The training collar for stubborn dogs helps in making your dog obedient effortlessly. If you choose the right collar for your dog and know its use then you can even train stubborn dogs.

My recommendation is the Sportdog 425x Remote Training Dog Collar as it has a blind operation design, 3 functional modes, and an effective range so, ideal for aggressive dogs.

Besides, share this write-up and drop your valuable feedback below to keep on improving my articles.

Naina Anuman

Similar Posts