Choosing the right training collar for a stubborn dog can be a daunting task. These collars are designed to help correct behaviors in dogs that are resistant to traditional training methods. In this article, we explore ten different training collars that are well-suited for stubborn dogs, each with unique features and benefits. Whether you need a collar with a long range, multiple training modes, or one that is especially durable, there is an option here to meet your needs.
Key Takeaways
- Understanding the specific needs of your stubborn dog is crucial in selecting the right training collar.
- Look for collars that offer customizable settings to ensure safe and effective training.
- Durability and waterproof capabilities are important features to consider for long-lasting use.
- Training collars with long-range capabilities provide more flexibility in various training environments.
- Always consult with a professional trainer or behaviorist to use training collars safely and effectively.
1. Pet Resolve Training Collar
When it comes to training stubborn dogs, I’ve found that the Pet Resolve Training Collar stands out as a top choice. It’s not just about the shock; it’s about effective communication and control. This collar offers a variety of modes including shock, vibration, and sound, which are essential for training sessions that require flexibility based on your dog’s sensitivity and response.
Key Features:
- Waterproof construction: Perfect for training in various weather conditions.
- Long-lasting battery: Ensures that you don’t have to worry about frequent recharges during intensive training sessions.
- Super long-range and memory: Ideal for off-leash training in large open areas.
- Affordable pricing: Makes it accessible without breaking the bank.
One thing I particularly appreciate is the ability to train up to three dogs simultaneously with additional collars. This feature is a game-changer for multi-dog households. The remote is user-friendly, allowing you to switch between modes and dogs with ease, making your training sessions as smooth as possible.
Note: Always start with the least intrusive methods like sound or vibration before moving to shock mode. It’s crucial to adjust the settings to suit your dog’s temperament and the specific training scenario.
2. SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425XS

I’ve had my fair share of challenges with training stubborn dogs, and let me tell you, the SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425XS has been a game changer. This collar is specifically designed for the more stubborn dogs, offering a variety of features that cater to intensive training needs.
Here’s what makes it stand out:
- 21 levels of static stimulation: You can adjust the intensity to match your dog’s sensitivity and response.
- 500-yard range: Ideal for training in larger outdoor spaces.
- Waterproof and submersible: No worries about water damage, this collar can handle it!
- Rechargeable batteries: Quick charging and long-lasting, perfect for extensive training sessions.
The collar also supports training up to three dogs with the same remote, making it a versatile choice for multi-dog households.
The combination of shock, vibrate, and tone settings allows for flexible training approaches, ensuring that you can find the right method that works for your dog. The remote is easy to use and lets you switch between different dogs and stimulation levels effortlessly. Whether you’re dealing with a hard-headed retriever or a willful terrier, this collar should be on your list.
3. Educator E-Collar Humane Dog Training Collar
When it comes to training a stubborn dog, I’ve found that the Educator E-Collar is a game-changer. It’s designed to be humane and effective, offering 100 levels of safe stimulation that can be adjusted to your dog’s sensitivity. The collar also features a unique tapping sensation, similar to vibration, which works wonders for getting your dog’s attention without harshness.
Key Features
- 100 levels of stimulation: Perfect for fine-tuning to your dog’s needs.
- Tapping sensation: A gentler alternative to traditional shocks.
- Night light: Great for evening training sessions.
- Waterproof and rechargeable: Ideal for all-weather training.
Why Choose This Collar?
This collar is not just about correcting behavior; it’s about teaching and reinforcing good behavior in a way that respects your dog’s physical and emotional well-being. The tapping feature, in particular, is a standout, providing a humane way to communicate with your dog effectively.
Remember, the key to successful training with an e-collar is consistency and patience. Always start with the lowest setting and gradually find the level that gets your dog’s attention without causing distress.
If you’re looking for a collar that combines technology with compassion, this is the one. It’s a tool that supports both training and the well-being of your dog, making it a top choice for pet owners dedicated to positive training methods.
4. PetSafe Elite Little and Big Dog Remote Trainers
When it comes to training both little and big dogs, the PetSafe Elite Remote Trainers are a game-changer. These trainers are designed to accommodate the varying needs of different dog sizes, making them incredibly versatile. The range of up to 100 yards and 16 adjustable levels of static correction, including an instant +2 Boost button, ensures that you can tailor the training to your dog’s temperament and the specific challenges you face.
Key Features
- Range up to 100 yards: Perfect for training in both indoor and outdoor settings.
- 16 adjustable levels of static correction: Allows precise control over the intensity of corrections.
- Instant +2 Boost button: Useful for immediate correction of unwanted behaviors.
- Tone-only mode: Alerts your pet with a beep without static correction, ideal for initial training phases or sensitive dogs.
The versatility and safety features of the PetSafe Elite make it an ideal choice for pet parents who need a reliable solution for training their dogs. With options like tone-only alerts and multiple correction levels, it ensures that training is not only effective but also humane.
5. Dogtra 1900S Series Ergonomic Shock Collar
I’ve been using the Dogtra 1900S Series Ergonomic Shock Collar for a while now, and let me tell you, it’s a game-changer for training stubborn dogs. This collar is not just about delivering corrections; it’s about providing a consistent and reliable tool that helps reinforce commands and correct behaviors effectively.
Key Features:
- Range: 3/4-mile
- Waterproof: Yes, fully waterproof
- Stimulation Levels: 0-127
- Design: Ergonomic, with a seamless strap design
The collar’s ergonomic design ensures it fits snugly around your dog’s neck, providing better skin contact and more effective stimulation. The wide range of stimulation levels means you can find the perfect intensity to match your dog’s sensitivity and response.
Why Choose Dogtra 1900S?
- Durability: Built to withstand harsh conditions
- Intuitive Design: Easy to use for both amateur and professional trainers
- Performance: High output and reliable in demanding situations
If you’re looking for a collar that combines durability, intuitive use, and high performance, the Dogtra 1900S should be at the top of your list. It’s particularly effective for headstrong canines who need a firm but fair approach to training.
Note: Always start with the lowest stimulation setting and gradually increase it to find the level that your dog responds to without distress.
This collar has helped me and many others gain better control during training sessions, making them more productive and less stressful for both the dog and the trainer.
6. PetSpy P620 Dog Training Shock Collar
I’ve been using the PetSpy P620 Dog Training Shock Collar for a while now, and I must say, it’s a game-changer for training stubborn dogs. This collar is not only effective but also incredibly user-friendly. It offers multiple training modes including vibration, shock, and beep, which are essential for training dogs with different sensitivities and behaviors.
One of the standout features of the PetSpy P620 is its adjustable intensity levels. This allows me to customize the training to suit my dog’s specific needs and threshold, ensuring that the training is both effective and humane. The collar is also waterproof, making it perfect for outdoor training sessions, no matter the weather.
The simplicity and effectiveness of the PetSpy P620 have made training sessions much more productive and stress-free.
Additionally, the long battery life and the range of the remote are quite impressive, allowing for uninterrupted training sessions over considerable distances. This is particularly useful in a park or large backyard settings.
Here’s a quick rundown of the key features:
- Multiple training modes: Vibration, shock, beep
- Adjustable intensity levels for tailored training
- Waterproof: Suitable for all weather conditions
- Long battery life and range: Ensures consistent training
Overall, the PetSpy P620 Dog Training Shock Collar has been a reliable tool in my journey to train my stubborn dog. It’s simple to use, works like a charm, and has really helped me teach my dog the right behaviors effectively.
7. Pet Union PT0Z1 Premium Training Shock Collar
When it comes to training stubborn dogs, the Pet Union PT0Z1 Premium Training Shock Collar stands out as a top choice. This collar is not only fully waterproof but also boasts a variety of adjustable training modes including shock, vibration, and beep, making it versatile for different training needs. The range of up to 1200ft allows for effective training in various environments, whether close or distant.
The collar’s design ensures that it is comfortable for your dog to wear for extended periods, which is crucial during the longer training sessions that stubborn dogs might require.
Here are some key features:
- Fully waterproof
- 4 adjustable training modes: Shock, Vibration, Beep
- Up to 1200ft range
This collar is particularly popular among both expert trainers and first-time pet owners due to its ease of use and effectiveness in handling the most stubborn of dogs.
8. Garmin Delta XC Bundle

I’ve been using the Garmin Delta XC Bundle for a while now, and I must say, it’s a game-changer for training stubborn dogs. This collar uses tri-tronics technology which makes it super easy to use, making it a perfect choice for both new dog parents and professional trainers. The best part? It has a save-setting system that allows you to save your optimal settings. Once saved, you just push one button to operate the settings automatically in sequence.
The Garmin Delta XC Bundle is not just about ease of use; it’s also about safety. It doesn’t leave any marks on your dog’s skin, thanks to the controlled shock intensity, making it a humane choice for training.
Additionally, the remote control of this device is top-notch. You can fully control the receiver, and it comes with a high-quality battery that lasts a long time. Imagine training your dog for three hours daily; you won’t need to recharge for about 30 days! This durability and efficiency make it a solid investment for any dog owner.
9. Dogtra 1902S 2-Dogs Remote Training Collar

I’ve been using the Dogtra 1902S 2-Dogs Remote Training Collar for a while now, and I must say, it’s a game changer for anyone with two dogs that are a bit hard-headed. This collar is part of the Dogtra 1900S series, known for its durability, dependability, and performance in demanding conditions. What sets the 1902S apart is its ability to train two dogs simultaneously with a single remote.
The collar features a 3/4-mile range and is fully waterproof, making it perfect for training in various environments. The receivers are sleek and designed to fit comfortably around your dog’s neck. With stimulation levels ranging from 0-127, it’s easy to find the right intensity to match your dog’s temperament and training needs.
Key Features:
Dual-dog training capability
3/4-mile range
Waterproof design
0-127 stimulation levels
The hands-free square feature is particularly impressive, allowing for easy training without constantly reaching for the remote. Priced at $429.99, it’s an investment in your dog’s training and overall behavior management. Based on my experience and the glowing reviews, the Dogtra 1902S is definitely worth considering if you’re looking for a reliable training solution for your dogs.
10. SportDOG Brand 425X Remote Trainers
I’ve got to say, the SportDOG Brand 425X Remote Trainers are a game-changer for anyone with a stubborn dog. This collar is designed to handle the most challenging training scenarios with ease. It offers a variety of features that make it stand out from the crowd. The 500-yard range is perfect for training in large open spaces, ensuring that your dog has the freedom to explore while still under control.
Here’s what makes it so great:
- 21 levels of static stimulation: This allows you to find the perfect intensity for your dog’s sensitivity and responsiveness.
- Vibration and tone options: These are great for training with commands that don’t require static stimulation.
- Waterproof construction: No worries about the elements, this collar can handle rain or shine.
- Rechargeable batteries: Quick charging and long-lasting, ideal for regular training sessions.
The SportDOG 425X is not just effective, it’s also built to last and easy to use, making it a top choice for professional trainers and everyday dog owners alike.
Wrapping It Up
Well, there you have it! Finding the best training collar for your stubborn dog doesn’t have to be a headache. With the right information and a little patience, you can select a collar that not only helps manage your dog’s behavior but also enhances your training sessions. Remember, the key is to choose a collar that is comfortable for your dog and suits their specific needs. Happy training, and here’s to a more obedient and happy pup!
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the key features to look for in a training collar for a stubborn dog?
When selecting a training collar for stubborn dogs, consider adjustable stimulation levels, range, waterproof capabilities, durability, and a comfortable fit for the dog’s size and temperament.
Are shock collars safe for training stubborn dogs?
Shock collars can be safe when used correctly and responsibly. It’s important to choose a collar with adjustable settings to ensure the stimulation is humane and effective for training without causing harm.
How do I use a training collar effectively on a stubborn dog?
Start with the lowest stimulation setting and gradually increase it only if necessary. Consistent training and positive reinforcement are key. Always supervise the dog while the collar is in use to monitor its impact.
Can training collars for stubborn dogs be used in any weather?
Many high-quality training collars are designed to be waterproof and durable, making them suitable for use in various weather conditions. Always check the specific features of the collar model you choose.
What is the ideal range for a training collar used on stubborn dogs?
The ideal range depends on your training environment. Collars with a range of 500 yards or more are beneficial for outdoor training where more space is involved.
How long does the battery typically last in a training collar?
Battery life varies by model, but many quality collars offer long-lasting batteries that can support extended training sessions or multiple days of use before needing a recharge.
Is it possible to train more than one dog with a single remote trainer?
Yes, some training collar systems are designed to control multiple collars with a single remote, allowing you to train more than one dog simultaneously. Check the product specifications for this feature.
What should I do if my dog does not respond to the training collar?
If your dog does not respond, reassess the fit and settings of the collar. Consulting with a professional trainer for guidance on effective use and alternative training strategies may also be beneficial.